Showing posts with label guy graybill. Show all posts
Showing posts with label guy graybill. Show all posts

Sunday, May 24, 2026

Remembering All Who Have Died To Support and Fight for the Peace We All Pray For... Spotlighting the Poetic Words of Guy Graybill from Rhymes from the Hinterland...

 




THE WALL OF NAMES 

Most walls are built to separate; 
But, this wall’s made to bind.
 It brings together fallen souls
 With loved ones left behind.
 This wall will span the ocean’s waves, 
This wall will span the years;
 And, though it sheds the pounding rains,
 It will absorb the tears.
 I watch, as others place bouquets.
 I hear them softly cry
 While making tracings of the names.
 They hope, the same as I.
 We pray . . . and hope to capture here, 
By tracing out the name,
 The spirit of a loved one lost,
 That we can hold and frame.
 Our son, they said, stepped on a mine
 That lay beneath the ground;
 But, no remains were gathered then,
 And none were ever found. 
They never sent a body bag.
 No “welcome” could occur.
 We held a dismal service; but,
 With nothing to inter.
 So I, too, trace my hero’s name.
 Upon the sheet it’s pressed.
 And, if I’ve caught his troubled soul,
 I’ll take it home to rest.
 And when, someday,
 we put aside
 All campaigns, great and small,
 We’ll know the world has finally learned
 The message of our wall.
~~~~





THE ROMANCE OF WAR

 Our young should know of war:

 That pre-historic way

 Men found to wound . . . to slay . . .

 To smear the land with gore!

 Our young should early learn

 That slaughter can be done

 To groups, as well as one; 

No mercy to discern. 

It might be well to teach

 That twisted minds delight

 In barbarism’s sight;

 ‘Though claims to ‘order’ preach.

 To help our young ignore

 The horror and the hell, 

We’ve made a myth, and well:

 The fine romance of war! 

This knowledge to bestow,

 We should with passion yearn.

 War’s TRUTH our young should learn;

 But war they should not KNOW!

!!!!!!


BATTLEFIELD REUNION

 Here we meet, don’t you know?

 Comrades now without foe.

 Here we camp and recall battle scenes.

 Now we sit by our tents,

 to compare past events,

 As we feast on a soup made with beans.

 Here we laugh and we sing

 while we have us a fling,

 For tonight we will not have a care.

 Yes, the kettles will steam

 and old comrades will beam,

 While the mem’ries of combat we share.

 So, we mingle with pride

 and take aging in stride.

 Soon our spirits are fully restored.

 Of our nation we brag

 and salute us a flag; 

Then we pause to give thanks to the Lord.

 But, I voice my dismay at the closing of day,

 As we rest under moon’s gentle light:

 Should we not shed a tear

 for dead comrades so dear,

 Who still haunt our old campground tonight?

~~~~~


THE GREAT WALL

 Across ten thousand hills it snaked its way

 And, as the largest structure ever made,

 Yet stands, a muted monument, today,

 To organizing genius there displayed.

 T’was built, we’re told, to benefit all those

 Who’d live in later centuries . . . safe . . . secure.

 “A life was spent for ev’ry stone that rose.”

 A price quite small to keep a culture pure.

 But, when the Khan desired his Hordes sent forth,

 Sung land was as a pantry filled with ants.

 The thousands ran, with ease, out of the North,

 To clamber o’er the Wall in their advance.

 One must conclude: It simply wasn’t built

 To help protect the peasant or his land;

 But, to maintain a dynasty in gilt,

 Against a fearsome Mongol warrior band.

 We’d hope a lesson might from this be learned:

 ‘Tis wrong to sacrifice someone today,

 For benefits presumed, once night has turned;

 ‘Cause Fate may change all factors on the way!

 Too many structures have been dearly built,

On footings made of human flesh and frame;

 Some structures are of architectural tilt.

 Far worse are those political in name.

 In recent years, in that brave land so old—

 That land where Wisdom’s said to have been born—

 More innocents have died, a million-fold;

 While loved ones, by the hundred millions, mourn.

 Digest, then, one small truth, Friend, if you can:

 Do not abuse frail life for any plan!

~~~~~~









From the historical Great Wall of China to the Wall of Names for the United States, all peoples cry out when a loved one dies. Especially in war... How do people accommodate to the loss, while at the same time knowing that their child might have died in vain... For this great war or that one, never to know when one or two power-hungry leaders will decide to take your son or daughter to "defend" our lives for this or that reason... 

Can we feel pride in that child who made the decision to act on behalf of our countries? Of course we can. Yet, at the same time, we can feel the loss, the pain, wondering how and when the pain will finally go away, now that their child will never come back...

Yet we must ponder... What is the difference of losing our children to never-ending war, while we also know we lose our most precious school children because of the instruments of war that proliferate the lives of those who live in homes where guns are readily available and even taught to our children, so that, when it becomes some magical appropriate age, they can be taught to learn how to kill with those guns... Some will be for food that they carry a gun; the majority carry a gun because they can, for no other reason than to show that they possess a power to "kill" whenever they want...

Guy Graybill, in my opinion, has presented us with four short stories about the act--the romance--of war... Yet, he provides a concurrent look at those who give up a child when they do not return home to their family... Yes, we commemorate those deaths--it seems we all feel that we must "do something" in recognition to lives lost... Many picnics and family gatherings are held on Memorial Day. But perhaps after a quick prayer, what is actually done to recognized the life of lost children?

I was impressed that so many new writers have written some wonderful songs for 2026. I have chosen from that group instead of those that have become "traditional" songs for the day, simply from year after years of the same type of celebration...

Today, however, after reading Guy's words more carefully, I find, once again, that I turn away from "tradition..." This is not a traditional time of war, is it? You can feel it across the nation--across the world... Now that we are able to communicate with those in different lands, and see the sight of children and others lying dead, civilians who are caught in wars created by those men who decide they want to play war and gain some type of recognition for doing so--or worse, have people across the world see the messes that have been caused, as people's homes are bombed, to see them walking to another land, sometimes walking back until the next battle begins...or becoming homeless, left to those who are able to bring them to another land where they have no home or shelter, no means of gaining a life that may become better, if allowed before another autocrat decided they don't deserve to be where they are and ship them off to some other place where they may or may not be welcomed...

Tell me, you who are committed to any religion... Why have you turned away from a loving eternal being who you claim to be your god? For me, I had chosen to follow Jesus when God gave us His Son...

Yet, even at that time, many turned away from that Gift... They chose Barabbas... Or they chose to continue to follow a religion that was based upon thousands of years of previously written words and rituals, believing that only in absolute following of rules and regulations that they would come to know God... Believing that they must give sacrificies in order to be seen and known by the Great I Am... How little did we listen to the words of the ancients...

Even in Biblical times, there was war, war and more wars... Yet, when Jesus was born, all of that was to be put aside...

Yet, right now, yes, right now, we are in the midst of a cold war within the United States...where murders occur on the streets, children are sexually abused and more by those who choose to act only because they see it as something or somebody who deserves to have the best--the young, the unblemished...How dare they! Right now, as one of the songs says, there is a division between the red and the blue... But there is also a war going on just for the pleasure of one man...He's destroying our national monuments, proclaiming his name as the owner... And there seems to be a minority, with money, who enjoy the misery that is being caused... He claims he has won 8 wars, which were never declared officially... And certainly had not compared in scope to the ugly hatret we discovered against Germany's Hitler, when millions were destroyed because of religion! In fact, many now think that Christian Nationalists are the group who should be running the United States... You know who they are...They invated the Capitol on Januaary 6th, threatened to hang Mike Pense and other leaders of Congress, and, now, with glee are thinking that the president is going to pay them for the damage, the deaths caused at the Capitol, because they did it as requested by the president at that time, based upon false claims that he had actually won the election...

As we look to the next national holiday, July 4th, and recognize the significance of the years, we MUST watch as priority is being used to create monuments to this president at the same time, as many people are now unable to meet basic needs while the republican party has stolen funds for private airplanes, military weapons that are being made by companies in which the president's family have interest and riches are pouring in... In fact, while The United States was given the Statue of Liberty to symolically recognize how America had opened our arms to millions across the world... we now see, for instance, the president stealing the look of a monument from France, I believe, while destroying the concept of lighting that made the nearby water display so spectacular...while claiming that we the people want a ballroom for the white house to be built by our money--money that many could use to feed their children, or buy clothes for school for them...

Folks, I never could have imagined that I, along with all people across the world, would have seen the day when large corporations and those rich men who do not pay comparable tax rates as we do, would be the ruling class of destruction to our Democracy... I still fail to comprehend how this could have happened--meaning, that I had been too naive to comprehend that many people care little about anything but themselves! May God forgive our Blindness...

Gabby 





Monday, March 16, 2026

For Love Presented by Ongoing Poetry Contributor Guy Graybill - Also, Love Enough! - The Prize - Nan

 


FOR LOVE 

(To the tune of “Simplice,” by Tchaikovsky)


Let’s steal away,
 To someplace where we can love;
 Where breezes are cool
 And passions will rule,
 While stars glitter high above.

 Let’s steal a kiss,
 A kiss that goes on and on;
 With boldness that grips
 Our hungering lips,
 While night fades into the dawn.

 Let’s find a nook
 Where I’ll be alone with you;
 Just hidden away
 An hour or a day;
 Or maybe a week or two.

 Let’s dare to dream:
 A dream that we’ll make come true.
 We’ll welcome the chance
 To make our romance
 A love that is always new.

 Let’s take a vow
 To live, evermore, as one.
 With light from above
 We’ll make the white dove
 The symbol for all we’ve done . . . For love.
💖





LOVE ENOUGH


 Yes, I’m a Hindu lover Sir
 And I love Nordics, just as well.
 I am a Negro (Black) lover, too;
 And ev’ry Semite, truth to tell.

Plus ev’ry Oriental type
 And natives of the U.S.A.
 And Eskimo and all the blends,
 Such as the oceans’ grand array.

 Perhaps I’ve got a malady; 
A trait that’s ever here and done.
 Simplistic, yes; but very true: 
I love God’s people, ev’ry one.

 What need to justify this trait?
 This observation’s not profound:
 When prejudice is kept at bay,
 There’s love enough to go around!

👼💓👼



💘
THE PRIZE
 
She, the white woman who taught in the village.
 He, the wild warrior, eas’ly tamed by her eyes.
 They lived together, apart from their people.
 Yes, they lived as outcasts; but they had the prize.

 They saw the glances, the looks and the hatred.
 They sensed the meanness that pure envy inspires. Then each would look in the eyes of the other
 And they would smile, knowing they had the prize.

Each day they thanked their Creator and Maker, While enduring the pain from the meddlesome lies. Each gained more strength from the love of the other; Still sharing a smile, knowing they had the prize.

Sadly, by moonlight, some bigots attacked them, Thus, leaving the couple to face their demise. Weakly, each searched for the eyes of the other. Tho’ dying, they smiled, knowing they had the prize. . . .

💞 

Nan


Of course, there is sorrow
And, yes, there are tears
For you, who grew sweeter
Through all of our years...

Your smile ever lingered
A joy I now miss
Although you grew weaker
Pale lips blew a kiss.

This pen I'm discarding
Our match to renew
I'll soon be abiding,
Forever with you. . . .


💗
Thank you for sharing your love, Guy

Gabby

 



Monday, February 16, 2026

Rhymes from the Hinterland - The Hypocrites - The Things Which Kill - An Event to Lament - The Solemn Swearers by Guy Graybill!

 



THE HYPOCRITES 


They dot their ev’ry ‘i’
And cross their ev’ry ‘t’. 
They’re perfect,
 so they claim,
 Compared to you and me.
 No rule may thus be bent
 By any human known.
 There’s nothing they’ll approve
 And nothing they’ll condone.
 With knowledge less than slight,
 They think they know too much;
 So those they find know more
 They claim are ‘out-of-touch’.
 Should ever you dispute
 The power they’ve assumed,
 There’s none can stay your fate.
 In wrath, you’ll be consumed!
 They summon all their friends,
 To quickly congregate.
 They made a super find:
 Another group to hate!
 With venom they condemn.
 Each boldly vilifies;
 With rumors lacking base
 And oft-repeated lies.
 At those who bend the rules,
 They’re first to cast a stone.
 There’s no exception seen
 Except, of course, their own!
~



THE THINGS WHICH KILL

 When blinded Polyphemus chose a rock
 To hurl at bold Odysseus in his flight,
 His weapon was as one from cave-man’s stock;
 Its simple function: death to expedite!
 But, even then, in that gray, Dorian dawn,
 New ways had been designed to maim and slay.
 The things which kill have ever come and gone,
 ‘Though killing’s stayed in fashion to this day. Creating weapons always leads the field
 Of scientific areas of advance. 
New, shining missiles are today revealed,
 As genius takes a military stance.
 But, whether made by genius or by fool,
 Each weapon’s still a gross, barbarian tool.
~


AN EVENT TO LAMENT

 The war has gone away. 
Who will we bomb today?
 Without a formal fight,
 What homes can we ignite?
 How will we stay in shape,
 If we can’t kill and rape?
 Without campaigns to win,
 What medals will they pin?
 Should peaceful times prevail,
 We’ll all be whole and hale;
 But, grit we can’t display.
 The war has gone away. . . .
~


THE SOLEMN SWEARERS

 When presidents declaim their oaths
 And utter to the fawning crowd,
 The nation looks,
 and glows with pride.
 Each native heart is justly proud.
 But, we all know—
if we’ll admit—
 The luster pales;
 the pride recedes.
 Each spotless one self tarnishes.
 Our leader changes as he leads.
 We might expect each aspirant,
 The august office to besmirch.
 We seek for men of noble mien;
 But, that’s an almost futile search.
 In fact, we’ve gone the other way.
 The ones that voters let survive,
 Not chancing image newly stained,
 Are tarnished well when they arrive!
~








Search on Guy Graybill for all posts...



Friday, January 23, 2026

Guy Graybill Presents Rhymes from the Hinterland - A Tome of Clever Poems!

Creator: BraunS | Credit: Getty Images
Copyright: BraunS


OUR YOUNG

They are safe as they play
Here among us today;
 But, how safe will they play
 On the morrow; 
Since the strangers came in,
 With a smile and a grin,
 Thus to buy
 What they never could borrow?
 Using money and guile
 And political style,
 They got land
 Which was prime and impressive.
 Will our young ones soon shrink
 From the water they drink,
 ‘Cause the toxins within are excessive?
 Will the strangers provide
 Waste for making our wide
 Susquehanna a river of sorrow?
 They are safe as they play
 Here among us today . . .
 But, will they safely play
 On the morrow?
~~~~

THE ROMANCE OF WAR

 Our young should know of war;
 That pre-historic way
 Men found to wound and slay . . .
 To smear the land with gore!
 Our young should early learn
!!!!




AN ACT OF SELF DEFENSE

 Her Smile is a rebel Smile.
 She knows the disarming art.
 Her lips bring to light her guile:
 A threat to my sov’reign heart.
💝

Guy Graybill's latest book is a compilation of written poems over the years--ones that were meant to be shared someday... Rhymes from the Hinterland brings to readers history, humor, romance and so much more... Guy has strong opinions; he shares them freely as one who writes poetry often does. For poetry is the words of need--a short time expressing what is in your mind or heart... 

Sometimes heavy with warning, sometimes light in joy of life. Sometimes he writes with words of old, yet, the meaning for today seems so clear...

THE VIGIL MAINTAIN

 So, you’ve put away all of your armor.
 So, your lance you have now set aside!
 And you say we have slain all the dragons?
 Here our thinking is bound to collide.

 You’re a fool, who is too soon deluded.
 Our world’s yet the dark, beast-laden wood.
 Here live creatures that hope to devour us;
 Here are foes who would do us no good.

 They are cloaked in a guise that is modern—
 Like the razor-sharp blade in the sheath—
 So that, outwardly, they appear harmless;
 But, the ‘dragon’ still lurks underneath!

 Some are nations that feign would embrace us; Others, groups that would offer us peace.
 Some are concepts that promise Utopia . . .
 The proverbial ‘wolves under fleece’?

 All those brutes would, with ease, overpower us,
 If we fell, importunely, asleep.
 So, we must have the moat filled with Caution
 And let Truth help us strengthen the keep.

 We’ve no choice but to maintain the vigil,
 And be certain our young can derive
 A concern for the imminent dangers.
 The alert are the ones who survive!
~~~~

UPBRINGING

 While I was yet an infant,
 My parents cast the die.
 They weaned me on bologna;
 They fed me rabbit pie.

 And as a lad, a-growing,
 They gave me kettle meat,
 Along with steaming mince pies,
Both savory and sweet.

 They set my tastes forever
 And didn’t even try.
 A carnivore they raised me;
 A carnivore I’ll die. 
😁

Some of my long-time readers will remember his book, Bravo, spotlighting music from Italy... I think I individually covered most of those individuals mentioned, more extensively at Book Readers Heaven. With this new book Guy has again become an ongoing contributor here, sharing over 160 poems found in this book through the upcoming moths or years... On the other hand, I've already read the entire book and can highly recommend it to all poetry readers. 

As mentioned, style of writing changes, based upon the topic... I find it delightful that he adds a touch of "theatre" to each poem...


 SUNRISE AND SADNESS 

When hopes lie shattered on the shore,
 Good friends are often wont to say:
 “The Sun will rise; just as before.
 Tomorrow is another day.”
 That’s what good friends are wont to say.

 But grave injustice came to call.
 Yes, grave injustice came to stay.
 So, I must dine on bitter gall 
And I’m condemned to sip dismay,
 No matter what good friends might say.

 On days when duties don’t impede,
 My will can’t push me from the cot.
 If bladder does not intercede,
 I’d rather slumber; rather rot,
 Than join a world where truth’s forgot!

 I curse the knaves who gain success
 By trampling ethics under hoof.
 One thought ignites my bitterness:
 I sense the crime; but lack the proof . . .
 I sense the crime; but lack the proof.
 To know injustice, unerased,

 Leaves morning’s joy forever gone;
 With courage lost and hope effaced.
 So long as justice is withdrawn,
 Sunrise and sadness crow the dawn . . .
😞

Folks, this last poem spoke to me,
  of attempts to progress backward...
For each day we see that,
 indeed, a failing justice

 How many thousands of years
 has this gone on,
 but never more
 than today's sad morn

I don't profess to be a poet,
Yet words speaking truth
do call to me...
Thus, a responsive attempt by me...
😍

Plan on seeing Guy around along with other contributors... In the meantime, I suggest that you get your own copy and place it next to where you sit... Turn the noise of news down  or read a poem or two during commercials. Each time a new one comes, you'll find that it may just speak to you as well...

GABixlerReviews



RELATIVE TIME 

“How it flies!” said the conquering Romans,
 Offering comment on Time’s rapid pace;
 And they’ve now made a clock run by atoms,
 Just to measure Time’s passage through space.

 Now, if life can flash by in an instant,
 And the earth, in a twinkling, will burn;
 Oh, then, why does an hour seem eternal,
 While I’m waiting for you to return?

💕


Tuesday, December 16, 2025

Long-Time Contributor, Guy Graybill, Announces Rhymes from the Hinterland--Just Out! Presenting Isle of Light

I've already talked with Graybill and have been given authority to share selections from this new book! Plan on seeing him as an ongoing contributor in the future... Or check out in the right column more of what he's been writing!


ISLE OF LIGHT 



As ancient tribal bowmen might fight a bowless band,
A nation’s modern weapon can crush a weaker land.
Upon a distant island, a plane was set on course;
Within, unseen in warfare, a new and Hellish force!




 The plane droned through the darkness; its crew a chosen few. 
They flew above the ocean; a somber, starlit view.
 Within the target city, no one foresaw the guest.
 Most rose to greet the new day; while slumber held the rest. . . . 


But, then arose a thousand suns; one blinding, searing flash! 
What Twilight bathed in glory, foul Dawn would bathe in ash! 
The victors won their skirmish, with soldiers undeployed. 
They also won their battle. The vanquished were destroyed. 

That bomb destroyed an empire. Proud leaders had to bow. 
But, that is all behind us; for we are here and now.
Soon, other nations differed and later wars were waged. 
Old conflicts are forgotten; Fate’s diary must be paged. 


My sadness overwhelms me. My sorrow overcomes, As I recall how fickle we’re made by martial drums.
 As decades drop behind us, the bomb begins to bore, As ‘just another weapon,’ in ‘just another war’. . . .
~
While historians speak of past wars, today we see the same
But this time something's different, the U.S. has lost its way
War is instigated by one man, instead of the government as a whole
Why is this allowed? We surely do not know...

Men who crave and lie for power
Who sit at home while citizens die
Cannot be allowed to continue to win
The rich get richer as widows and children cry...

Who are we who only choose peace
We lose so many in response to so few
When the majority wants only for wars to cease
Who are we? Who want only Peace...

Gabby







Do YOU Remember the Reason for the Season???

Saturday, December 23, 2023

Guy Graybill Presents Biography and Analysis of Henry Wharton Shoemaker: Scoundrel of the Susquehanna

 

THE INDIANIST PERIOD 

In the western United States, during the late 19th century, the national government was still trying to ‘tame’ the Native Americans, with General George Armstrong Custer trying to pave his path to the White House on the corpses of native Americans of all ages and genders. However, an interest in romanticizing the Native Americans was building in the eastern part of the country. 

In the 1840s, a woman named Marion Dix Sullivan, who had journeyed by canal boat on Pennsylvania’s Juniata River, was inspired by the journey to write the music for a celebratory song about the river. Mrs. Sullivan of New England wrote the music, and her husband, J.S. Sullivan, wrote the words, and the song became so popular that Marion Dix Sullivan became the nation’s first commercially successful female songwriter! Her song was a very popular song that romanticized the Native Americans. Her song was entitled “Blue Juniata.” The reader is urged to find several internet versions of the song to better understand the song’s considerable popularity. The American Civil War has accounts of “The Blue Juniata” being heard in both Union and Confederate army camps. Similarly, Laura Ingalls Wilder, author of the famed Little House books, wrote of her mother singing that song and of her father playing the song on his fiddle. 


Wondering how likely it was that the song “Blue Juniata might have influenced Henry W. Shoemaker,” this author checked the distance of Shoemaker’s McElhattan estate from the Juniata River, the subject of the song’s lyrics. The Juniata River is a large tributary of the Susquehanna River, and the Juniata’s nearest waters (Jack’s Creek) would flow near Bannerville, Pennsylvania, just about three dozen miles due south of Henry Shoemaker’s Restless Oaks estate in McElhattan. However, I later found evidence that Shoemaker was, indeed, not simply familiar with the song; but that he worked some of its lines into one of his own stories, the one cited as “The Siren.”

In the early 20th century, when Shoemaker was very much involved in his writing projects and manufacturing his versions of ‘folklore,’ American composers were known as “Indianists” who wrote considerable popular music based on American Indian themes. From my old personal copies of the era’s Etude music magazine, I can pluck the following songs: “Indian Love Song” by Charles Wakefield Cadman (June 1924) “By The Waters of Minnetonka” by Thurlow Lieurance (September 1922)... “March of the Indian Phantoms” (E.R. Kroeger) (October 1920)

This author would recommend that the reader find versions of any of these songs on the internet. My opinion is that Lieurance’s “By The Waters of Minnetonka” is among the most beautiful music of its type. A 1907 Indian-flavored song is “Redwing.” The music seems to be ‘Indian sounding,’ although the melody was borrowed from a European composer (Robert Schumann). The result is lovely, in any case. 

Random finds in the music field also enriched this listing of possible influences on Henry Shoemaker’s choice of the Native Americans as a topic for many of his tales. The Etude magazine, in one lone issue (February 1927), told us (page 91) that the Royal Albert Hall of London was offering a season of the cantata “Hiawatha” with a noted Mohawk baritone in the cast. That same issue (page 132) offered readers two musical selections suitable for movie houses, one of which is a brief allegro feroce composition that carried the simple title: “Indians.” 

INSPIRED BY THE CLASSICS? It appears doubtful that Henry Shoemaker learned little folklore in backwoods hunting camps or rustic taverns. What does seem evident is that some of his plots were plucked from other uncredited sources, including a couple of the world’s most notable earlier plots. One, in particular, seems to have been lifted from an old Roman tale, and another borrowed from either Homer or Heine. Let’s consider these. 

ANDROCLES REBORN? How simple for Henry Shoemaker to refashion one of antiquity’s most popular legends into a backwoods adventure. Although I’m not a betting gent, I’d be quite willing to wager a modest sum on this likelihood: Shoemaker’s tale of “The View Tree,” cited previously, was inspired by a famous Roman legend of antiquity. The adventure of Shoemaker’s Peter Pentz character, surviving the threat of a 500-member wolf pack because Pentz had once helped an injured wolf, was the story found in the ancient classic Androcles and the Lion. The legend of Androcles told of Androcles’s life being spared because he had once removed a thorn from a lion’s paw. In his story of “The View Tree,”25 Shoemaker has his hero, a noted hunter named Peter Pentz, come upon a wounded wolf. Although he normally, almost naturally, killed wolves, Peter Pentz decided to fix this wolf’s mangled paw. He created splints and used them to aid the paw’s healing. Sometime later, Pentz is being pursued by nine Indians and barely escapes by climbing a chestnut tree of about 90 feet in height and obscuring himself in the tree’s branch-filled top. His savage pursuers guessed he was in the tree and eventually decided to create fire around the chestnut tree’s trunk, knowing that Pentz would be killed when the great fire-weakened tree toppled! However, Shoemaker creates an even-more imminent danger for his hero. A wolf pack emerged into the clearing where Pentz was treed!...
~~~

Author and historian Guy Graybill presents the mind-boggling analysis of the various falsehoods of folklorist, naturalist, and collector, Henry Wharton Shoemaker.

I found myself laughing as I got further and further into Guy Graybill's latest book, Henry Wharton Shoemaker, for which he gives the concluding title: Scoundrel of the Susquehanna...You see, Guy Graybill is an historian, a dedicated one, that, when he gets into a subject to be considered and written about, he moves deeply and strongly to ensure that he presents exactly what he feels is needed...

I laughed because I began to picture the "Guy Graybills" in, say, the year 3000, when they attempt to create a similar book on our immediate past president... But, as I contemplated this, I realized that it might be quite easy and not the extensive work that Graybill presents in this book. After all, I remember that CNN was keeping track of all the lies and pieces of misinformation that happen daily. Even though there are millions who now and probably will forever believe all of the false rhetoric that was spewed during the last years when Donald Trump, also a rich man, like Shoemaker, came to leave his "celebrity" of a TV reality show and moved into the White House...
 
All that is to say, folks, that I sensed a God Incident happening for me... I'll let you think through the chain of events... Sometime months ago I had heard from Guy about his new book. I'm assuming it was during some period of health issues which prevented me from doing reviews and I didn't respond. However, for the first time ever, Guy sent me a Christmas card, which arrived, the same day I completed and posted my last review. Yes, the one I called important (and still think so). But by the time I reached Guy's moving into music, the picture of Jesus laughing--at me--came to my mind... "This, too, shall pass away. Trust Truth...

I have to say, folks, that a weight has been lifted from my heart. I did my research, found my answer, and recognized that the task was beyond my capability to resolve... And, that, Truth will indeed come to All...in His Time... Almost like He was saying, "I Got This..."

I could feel my similar tension in Graybill's writing and creating this book about a scoundrel who, for his own egotistical purposes, started writing books by taking themes, concepts, and other issues, including the signing of the constitution...and creating a book telling a totally different story than the truth, and then...building monuments to himself... They were small monuments, perhaps, but they were built on lies, fabrications, fiction... Graybill's book differentiates between the genre of Folklore by sharing from the scoundrel's own mouth and adding his own comment:
“The writer has endeavored to transcribe the legends exactly as he heard them from the very old people, but as in the case with his previous volumes of Pennsylvania Mountain folklore, he has exercised the right to change the names of persons, places, dates, etc.”
What? From whom did he obtain the right to alter any portion of his stories? By his own admission, he was reserving the right to change folklore into fact! What an astonishing admission! In the above paragraph, Henry Wharton Shoemaker told his readers that they had no reason to believe a single word he had ever written! One ponders: Where better to learn the value of literary truth than within the writings of a prolific scoundrel?

I first learned of literary truth when I began working with a publisher over a decade ago. I was reading and editing a book which was about Vietnam... I loved it. The publisher scanned it and started talking about mistakes... I was, of course, thinking of proofreading mistakes. No, these were about dates, places and people... For me, reading fiction, I rarely considered whether specifics like this were real. I was to learn that day of "literary truth" that when an author writes an historical novel, even as fiction, some basic research had to be done to place the scenes, plots, et.al. This was truly a wakeup for me because I realized just how important and time-consuming such research would be for those who chose to write about history.

As Graybill blasted through story after story, debunking details, I soon became mind-boggled, just as the book description stated! The extent of this man's disinformation carried throughout his writings, just as disinformation carries through Trump's rhetoric... 

But, Graybill, rightly presents a fairly extensive biographical sketch of Shoemaker. He was born in 1880 in New York City and into an affluent family. He was the oldest so was to inherit a considerable fortune, as well as the privilege afforded to those in the right circles... At one point Henry owned six newspapers in Pennsylvania. His grandparents owned several thousands of rural land, which they called Villa Vista, but, as the ownership finally reached Henry, he quickly changed the name to Restless Oaks. 

It was during Shoemaker's college years that Graybill began to find discrepancies. For instance, he would list himself as a graduate of Columbia. When attempting to verify this basic information, the school identified him as a non-graduate as of 1901. While attending, he did, however, become very active socially and this was to continue into his older years when at one time he was a member of many different organizations, which, it appears he joined in order to make a name for himself, because it was shortly after he left college in 1901 that he was appointed as a diplomat to Cost Rica by President Theodore Roosevelt. Then moving on to Lisbon, Berlin, and finally as Ambassador to Bulgaria...

The parallel to Trump seemed to end at the point where Shoemaker never really held a real point of power and, perhaps, this led to what he began to do... By merging his property interests, his traveling, and his love of writing, Shoemaker maneuvered to make his name known into posterity... Through, again, connections and memberships, he was able to become involved in creating historical monuments for the State of Pennsylvania--each one to include his full name and position...

So, bottomline, this is how it worked. He wrote a story(ies) that could be considered Folklore--those stories which were spread by word of mouth as to events that happened early in history... For instance, a story about the buffalo which once roamed across the state of Pennsylvania... Add a little fiction about meeting a man who had killed 2000, add that he did it in some part of the State...and, in his other capacity, Shoemaker would create a memorial sign, or in this case, a stone
This is real; book has pic of stoned!
buffalo... with sign with, of course, Shoemaker's name of authorization and verification!


I wanted to point out something that I wouldn't have normally known, except I'm having trouble with reading small print... I read the ebook version, and, the pictures were able to be studied as they appear on our phones... a horn, for instance, that was found with printing on it, can easily be enlarged and studied. I found this much more interesting than just looking at the book pictures... So depending upon just how much time you want to invest, to survey the debunking work of Guy Graybill debunking Henry Wharton Shoemaker, I'd recommend the ebook copy.

On the other hand, attempting to document an ongoing activity makes the book tedious and somewhat difficult to follow. For instance, the story of the bison, first was reviewed by experts who confirmed no physical evidence of the bison within the State of Pennsylvania. Also, each area within the folklore story had to be checked against historical sites as well as present... And, as Shoemaker often did, he would change his story's information from one story to the next, and finally, the "possibilities" of what was being written had to be studied. For instance, evaluating the place of the buffalo herd in relation to the amount of open land where the buffalo would have roamed... Considerations may include source of water as being available...

I learned much about the actual process used in documenting historical information, sites...and more. Enough to know that I'll leave it to Historian Guy Graybill! You might want to search in the right-hand column of my blog for "Guy Graybill," the range of his interests and books is extensive and I've read most of them. My favorite is his book covering Italian music of all kinds... Here's an easy click for a sample of that book and music! In fact, it's been years since I've shared from that book... Watch for something soon...

I applaud Graybill for taking on this monumental research task... Especially since we are in a period where lies and false stories are acceptable for many... For those who want Truth ONLY. We need those who will work to do the research and then be courageous enough to speak out! Kudos, Once Again! To Author!


GABixlerReviews