Showing posts with label Harold Michael Harvey. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Harold Michael Harvey. Show all posts

Friday, November 13, 2026

Harold Michael Harvey - Ongoing Contributor - Shares Thank You For The Blue Wave and Mississippi: The South Has Finally Risen Again!

 Mississippi votes in first Black Senator from the State in latest race for Congressional changes!






Thank You For The Blue Wave

A Prayer for America at the Breaking of a New Day




Saturday, October 3, 2026

Ongoing Legal Contributor Harold Michael Harvey Presents "When the State Cannot Kill Cleanly - Justice is Out of Balance"

 


Photo: AI-generated depicting justice out of balance.



When the State Cannot Kill Cleanly - Justice is Out of Balance


I have spent much of my life thinking about death, not in the abstract, but in the way the state prepares to take a human life in the name of justice. For two decades, I worked as a criminal defense lawyer in Georgia. When I closed my practice, I had successfully defended five Black men from execution in the Georgia electric chair, the capital punishment method in use in the last century. I fought those cases hard because I did not want to stand inside the execution chamber in Jackson, Georgia.


And for all those years, I never did, not until I went as a layman to protest the execution of Troy Davis on September 11, 2011, a moment that still sits heavy on my spirit. In nine days, Troy Davis would have turned 59 years old.

I have been a lifelong opponent of capital punishment. Only once did I ever believe the death penalty might be morally justified. It was in the Dylann Roof case, where Roof murdered 15 members of a Bible study group at the Mother Emanuel African Methodist Episcopal Church in Charleston, South Carolina, on June 15, 2015. The church had invited
him in for solace. Even then, I felt the weight of the question, not the righteousness of the answer.


Tonight, as I read the NBC News report on Tennessee’s failed execution of Christa Gail Pike, I am troubled in a way that reaches back through every capital case I ever handled.


Because what Tennessee attempted was not an execution. It was a collapse of state power. Simply put, a process the state could not control.

The facts are stark. Witnesses reported that executioners injected both syringes of lethal injection chemicals, yet Pike “has not lost consciousness and still has a heartbeat.” Journalists heard her say, “My arm feels like it’s about to burst open” at 7:34 p.m. They saw her kicking her feet, snoring, and knocking off the sheets laid on her body. At times, the curtain was closed, and journalists could only hear sounds.


Twice, officials closed the curtains, hiding the process from public view.

An ambulance arrived at the prison and then left again as medical aid was administered inside the death chamber. Even the victim’s mother, who wanted the execution carried out, said simply: “It was a mess.”

This was Tennessee’s second failed execution this year. In
May, executioners could not find a vein for Tony Carruthers, forcing a one‑year reprieve.

When a state cannot reliably carry out its gravest punishment, the punishment itself becomes morally indefensible. I have seen this system from the inside. I defended men the state intended to kill. I sat in rooms where prosecutors spoke casually about death. I sat with families who feared the phone call that would end their world. I sat with clients failed by every institution long before they ever met me. I saw the relief in their eyes when death was taken off the table.

In 2011, I felt the collective weight of protesters who had waited all day for a phone call from Justice Clarence Thomas that could save Troy Davis’s life. I’m still haunted by the collective murmur that erupted in the crowd when Ben Jealous announced that Thomas denied Davis’s last appeal, then Raphael Warnock emerged from the death chamber with the words, it is finished.


I also sat in policy discussions when Georgia considered eliminating electrocution in favor of lethal injection. We argued that capital punishment was cruel and unusual under all circumstances. The prevailing argument then was that lethal injection would be “more humane,” “more predictable,” and “less traumatic” for everyone involved.

But the Pike attempt shows what I suspected even then: the state cannot guarantee a humane death, not with electricity, not with chemicals, and not with any method that relies on human hands, human judgment, and human fallibility. As the Pike case shows, the body does not always cooperate.

The state’s spokesperson insisted Tennessee “followed every step of the State’s lawful, established execution. They insisted Tennessee “followed every step of the State’s lawful, established execution protocol” and that the chemical “has consistently been effective.”

But the human body is not a protocol. It is not a machine. It does not always respond to chemicals the way the state expects.

When Pike remained conscious, breathing, and in pain after both syringes were administered, the state’s claim of “consistency” collapsed.

Let’s be clear, trauma cannot be separated from the process. Pike’s lawyers argued that being strapped down would trigger “severe mental suffering and superadded psychological terror” because she had been molested and raped beginning in early childhood: trauma the state did not dispute at a recent hearing.

Even if the chemicals had worked perfectly, the psychological harm was already built into the process. A humane execution is impossible when the process itself recreates the trauma that shaped the defendant’s life.

Here is the moral question we cannot avoid.

I defended men the state intended to kill because I believed, and still believe, that the death penalty is a power too great for any government to wield. It requires perfection from inherently imperfect institutions. It requires certainty from systems built on human judgment. It requires control over a process that cannot be fully controlled.

The Pike attempt proves this again. If the state cannot kill cleanly, it should not kill at all.

When I stood outside the prison in Jackson to protest the execution of Troy Davis, I felt the weight of every client I had ever defended. I felt the weight of every mistake the justice system has ever made. And I felt the weight of the question that has followed me my entire career:

What does it do to a society when the state kills in its name?

Tonight, Tennessee answered that question in the worst possible way. It showed us that the death penalty is not justice. It is not closure. It is not control. It is a system that fails publicly, painfully, and predictably.

When the state fails at killing, everyone involved carries the burden: the condemned, the victims’ families, the witnesses, the courts, and the society that allows it. I have spent my life fighting this system. Tonight reminds me why.

~~~~~~

Harold Michael Harvey is an award-winning photojournalist and a two-time award-winning author. He is a 2026 Barrier Beakers Award Honoree, presented by the James Wimberly Institute for Black Studies & History, for his book Fantasy Five: The Election of Macon’s First Black Councilmembers. Please follow him at www.haroldmichaelharvey.com and haroldmichaelharvey.com.substack.com.


My friend always has the right words to pinpoint many important issues. I personally have mixed feelings about capital punishment, especially as pinpointed by Harvey for serial crime actions, when I see so many deaths being, seemingly, performed by the government itself: Minnesota murders in our streets, murder of unknown people in South America waters, and, of course, the deadly war on Iran which was not approved by anybody... Especially when a supreme court has given this president total immunity while he's in office! Can we afford to allow any deaths, even seemingly justified, to this government as being immuned???



Saturday, August 15, 2026

Harold Michael Harvey Presents Timely Article: The Breaking Point - When Neglect of Deployed Service Members Become a Failure of Leadership...

 

Photo: AI-generated image depicting the USS Abraham Lincoln out to sea.

THE BREAKING POINT

When Neglect of Deployed Service Members Becomes a Failure of Leadership



For as long as the United States has maintained a standing military, the nation has asked young men and women to bear burdens that civilians rarely see and seldom understand. We call them heroes. We honor their sacrifice. We speak reverently of the Commander‑in‑Chief’s solemn duty to protect them. But history shows that the distance between rhetoric and reality can be vast, and that the cost of that distance is often paid in the minds, bodies, and lives of the troops themselves.



Today, that cost is being paid aboard the USS Abraham Lincoln, stationed in the Strait of Hormuz, where sailors are reporting conditions that no modern fighting force should endure: mental‑health breakdowns, hygiene failures, exhaustion, and a level of strain that threatens both readiness and human dignity. Their suffering is not an isolated hardship. It is part of a recurring pattern in American history, a pattern in which young service members bear the cost of leadership failures they did not create and cannot fix.


This moment forces a question that Americans rarely ask aloud: When does neglect of deployed service members rise from policy failure to constitutional breach?



I. The Commander‑in‑Chief’s Duty of Care: A Constitutional Obligation

Article II of the Constitution grants the President command authority over the armed forces. But authority without responsibility is tyranny. The Commander‑in‑Chief’s role carries a corresponding duty to ensure that troops deployed in the nation’s name are properly supported, adequately equipped, mentally and physically protected, given clear and lawful missions, and treated with dignity.


This is not ceremonial language. It is the bedrock of American civil‑military ethics. When sailors aboard the Lincoln report that they are living in conditions that degrade their mental health, hygiene, and safety, the Commander‑in‑Chief’s constitutional obligations are implicated directly.

The President’s duty is not simply to command the military. It is to safeguard the people who make that command possible.



II. History’s Warning: Neglect Is Never Accidental

The crisis aboard the Lincoln echoes earlier failures that scarred generations of service members.

Vietnam

Troops were sent into an unclear mission with shifting objectives, inadequate support, and psychological trauma that lasted decades. The nation asked them to fight a war it could not explain.

Iraq (2003–06)

Young soldiers and Marines were sent into IED‑heavy environments without proper armor or equipment. They welded scrap metal onto Humvees because leadership had not prepared for the war it launched.

USS George Washington Suicides (2019-2022)

Sailors trapped in shipyard conditions so demoralizing that multiple lives were lost. The Navy called it “unfortunate.” Families called it preventable.

Post‑Vietnam Veterans

Returned home to inadequate mental‑health care, homelessness, and stigma. PTSD was not formally recognized until 1980. The nation abandoned the very people it had sent into harm’s way.

In each case, the pattern was unmistakable: young service members paying the price for leadership that failed to meet its obligations.

The Lincoln is not a new story. It is the latest chapter in an old one.


III. The Strait of Hormuz: Strategic Drift and Human Consequences

The Strait of Hormuz is one of the most volatile choke-points on earth, a place where geopolitical tension, naval risk, and operational stress converge. Deploying a carrier there without clear mission parameters, predictable rotation schedules, adequate mental‑health infrastructure, and humane living conditions creates conditions that are not merely difficult. They are dangerous.


History teaches that when troops do not know why they are deployed, how long they will remain, or what success looks like, mental‑health strain becomes inevitable. Strategic drift becomes human suffering. And the burden falls on the youngest, least powerful members of the military hierarchy.

This is not “the hardship of military life.” It is an avoidable harm.


IV. The Invisible Burden: Who Pays the Price for Leadership Failure

The sailors aboard the Lincoln are not abstractions. They are nineteen‑year‑olds on their first deployment, young parents separated from their children, working‑class Americans who enlisted for opportunity, and service members who believe in the mission even when the mission is unclear.

They serve in an institution that relies on their labor but rarely hears their voices. Their suffering is often invisible to the public, and too often ignored by leadership.

The question is not whether military life is hard. The question is whether the hardship they are experiencing is necessary, or the result of leadership neglect.


V. The Constitutional Question: When Does Neglect Become a Breach of Duty?

The Constitution defines impeachable offenses as: “Treason, bribery, or other high crimes and misdemeanors.”

“High crimes and misdemeanors” does not mean criminal violations. It means abuse of power, dereliction of duty, betrayal of public trust, and failure to execute the office faithfully.

So, we must ask:

If the Commander‑in‑Chief knowingly or should have known, yet allows deployed service members to live in conditions that degrade their mental health, hygiene, and safety, at what point does that neglect become a constitutional violation rather than a policy failure?

Legal scholars have long argued that gross negligence, reckless disregard for troop welfare, systematic failure to provide humane conditions, and ignoring known mental‑health crises can constitute a breach of the President’s constitutional obligations.

Whether Congress chooses to act is a political question. But the constitutional argument is legitimate and unavoidable.


VI. The Breaking Point

The crisis aboard the USS Abraham Lincoln forces a reckoning:

When leaders fail the people who depend on them, the people suffer, and the Constitution provides mechanisms for accountability.

This is not about politics. It is about stewardship. It is about whether the nation honors the people who serve it, not with slogans, but with humane conditions, clear missions, and leadership that treats their lives as sacred.

The sailors aboard the Lincoln deserve more than sympathy. They deserve leadership that meets its constitutional obligations.

And the nation deserves an answer to the question their suffering raises; an answer that cannot be delayed, deflected, or softened. How long can a democracy tolerate neglect of its most vulnerable defenders before it admits the truth that such neglect is not merely a failure of leadership, but a failure of duty so profound that it threatens the very integrity of the office entrusted with their lives?

~~~~~~



Monday, July 6, 2026

Ongoing Contributor Harold Michael Harvey Presents Power Without Mercy - A Message for ALL!


 


POWER WITHOUT MERCY

When a Superpower’s Strength Outgrows the Mercy That Should Restrain It