On Friday, November 6, three days after voters handed control of Congress to the Democrats, President Trump recorded an interview with 60 Minutes in which he conceded that his deportation policy “might be too tough.” On the same day, he named Stephen Miller, the chief architect of that policy, as his White House chief of staff. Presidents often say one thing and do another. What makes this case worth examining is that the saying and the doing happened within hours of each other, and the doing is the more reliable guide to what the next two years will bring.
CBS aired the interview, conducted by Ross Douthat, on Sunday, November 8. Asked whether his deportation policy had been too aggressive, the president answered, “I think it was too tough. I think it might be too tough.” He said the issue had “both helped and hurt” him in the midterm elections, and in the same conversation he gave himself an “A+” for closing the border. Exit polling reported by CBS found that 58 percent of voters believed the administration’s actions on immigration had gone too far.
The concession deserves a careful reading. The president did not say the policy was wrong. He said it might be too tough, noted that many people consider it a success, and framed the matter chiefly as a question of political cost. That is the language of a man measuring the electorate, not the language of a man changing course. Read in isolation, the interview might suggest a president absorbing a message from the voters. Read alongside the personnel announcement made the same day, it suggests something else.
Senate Democratic Leader Chuck Schumer reduced the problem to a single line: “That’s not a course correction. That’s a promotion.” The remark is partisan, but the observation is accurate on its face. A president who believed his immigration policy had gone too far would be unlikely to elevate the official most responsible for that policy to the most powerful staff position in the White House.
Miller is not a newcomer to power. He served as a senior adviser throughout the first Trump administration and has been Deputy Chief of Staff since the second term began on January 20, 2025. He was a central figure in the 2018 policy that separated thousands of immigrant families at the border as a deterrent. Between administrations, he led America First Legal, an organization of former Trump officials that pursued litigation against the Biden administration, universities, and media companies.
Miller’s relationship to Project 2025 requires precision, because imprecision here is easily exploited. Miller did not write Project 2025. America First Legal, however, was listed on the project’s advisory board until July 2024, when, as Democrats pressed the issue during the campaign, the organization asked to have its name removed. Miller told ABC News at the time that he had “zero involvement” with the project beyond a training video. Gene Hamilton, who leads America First Legal alongside Miller, drafted the Project 2025 chapter on the Department of Justice. The accurate description, then, is that Miller’s influence on the project came through proximity rather than authorship: his organization advised it, his closest colleague wrote part of it, and he has now been placed in charge of the staff that implements it.
The promotion matters because of what a chief of staff does. The position oversees the entire White House staff and manages the daily operations of the presidency, including who and what reaches the president. Miller replaces Susie Wiles, the longest-serving chief of staff of either Trump administration, who moves to the president’s political operation. A deputy shapes policy in his own portfolio. A chief of staff shapes the whole machine.
The Heritage Foundation has published its Mandate for Leadership series since 1981, offering each incoming conservative administration a set of policy recommendations. The 2023 edition, Mandate for Leadership: The Conservative Promise, became the centerpiece of Project 2025. Russell Vought, now Director of the Office of Management and Budget, wrote its chapter on the Executive Office of the President, and his Center for Renewing America sat on the project’s advisory board.
How much of the plan has been carried out? Two sources with opposite sympathies offer nearly the same answer. The Center for Progressive Reform, working with Governing for Impact, reported in February 2026 that the administration had initiated or completed 283 of the 532 domestic policy actions the project recommended across twenty federal agencies, or 53 percent, within twelve months of the inauguration. The president of the Heritage Foundation has since claimed that more than half of the project’s recommendations have been implemented. When the authors of a plan and its sharpest critics arrive at the same figure, the figure deserves to be taken seriously.
A caution is in order. The phrase “initiated or completed” covers actions at different stages, and some have been stopped or slowed in the courts. The figure does not mean that half of Project 2025 is settled law. It does mean that the document has functioned as a working agenda rather than as a think-tank wish list.
The most telling evidence predates the election. On November 1, two days before the vote, Reuters reporters Nandita Bose and Tim Reid reported that the White House had spent months preparing for a possible Democratic takeover of Congress. According to a White House official and two people familiar with the plans, officials had identified executive actions on immigration, tariffs, housing, and spending that could proceed without legislation, and the White House intended to seek legal opinions from the Justice Department on what the president could do without Congress and how to defend those actions in court. Asked how comfortable the president would be governing through executive authority under a Democratic Congress, one source answered, “very comfortable.” The president himself said he would become “Mr. Veto,” issuing vetoes for “a month or two” before reaching compromises.
Seen in this light, the Miller appointment looks less like a reaction to defeat than like the execution of a contingency already in place. That is an inference, not a documented fact, and it should be weighed as one. But it is the inference that best fits the sequence: a plan to govern around Congress prepared before the election, a lost Congress, and then the promotion of the aide most closely identified with the administration’s most aggressive use of executive power.
Defenders of the administration will raise several arguments, and they deserve a fair hearing. Every modern president facing a hostile Congress has turned to executive power; President Obama famously spoke of governing with “a pen and a phone.” Heritage has advised Republican administrations for more than four decades, and the foundation has claimed that the first Trump administration adopted 64 percent of the recommendations in its 2016 edition during its first year. Project 2025 was published openly, and voters elected the president knowing it existed. A chief of staff is a manager, and a president is entitled to choose one he trusts. In the same interview in which he called his policy too tough, the president floated the possibility of an immigration deal with Democrats.
These points are not frivolous. Executive power is not illegitimate in itself, and loyalty is not a disqualification for staff service. The question is not whether this administration will use executive power, but what kind of use it intends. Three features distinguish the present case. The first is breadth and speed: more than half of a 532-item domestic agenda set in motion within a single year. The second is preparation: the plan to govern around an elected Congress was drawn up before the voters had spoken, not in response to what they said. The third is design. Vought’s chapter treats the Office of Management and Budget as an instrument for extending direct presidential control over the federal agencies. Changes to the structure of government outlast any single policy, and they are far harder for a future Congress or administration to undo.
If those structural changes prove difficult to reverse, then the midterm result will constrain the remaining two years of this presidency far less than voters may assume. That, rather than any single executive order, is the question to watch.
The appointment of Stephen Miller is not merely a personnel change. It is a statement of governing strategy. The election told the administration that a majority of voters wanted restraint, particularly on immigration. The president acknowledged that message in words on national television. With the appointment, he answered it in action. When words and actions diverge, the historian’s rule is to follow the actions.
In a republic, elections are the means by which the governed correct those who govern them. The test of the next two years is whether that correction still works when the executive has prepared in advance not to receive it.
Dr. Michael A. Smith is a historian, author, and college professor.
Sources
ABC News. “Pro-Trump Group Asks to Be Removed from Project 2025 Advisory Board: Sources.” July 2024.
Al Jazeera. “Trump Says His Immigration Policy ‘Too Tough’ for Voters.” November 9, 2026.
Altman-Devilbiss, Alexx. “Trump Names Stephen Miller Chief of Staff, Replacing Susie Wiles.” The National News Desk, November 6, 2026.
Bose, Nandita, and Tim Reid. “Trump White House Maps Path to Govern without Congress if Democrats Win.” Reuters, November 1, 2026.
CBS News. “Trump Says His Deportation Policy Might Have Been ‘Too Tough’ in 60 Minutes Interview.” November 8, 2026.
Center for Progressive Reform. “Project 2025 Executive Action Tracker.” Updated February 2026.
Figueroa, Ariana. “Trump Open to Immigration Deal, Calls Crackdown ‘Too Tough,’ Despite Miller Promotion.” States Newsroom, November 9, 2026.
Heritage Foundation. Mandate for Leadership: The Conservative Promise. Washington, DC: Heritage Foundation, 2023.
Rykowski, Peter. “Trump Admin Implements More Than Half of Project 2025, Heritage’s President Claims.” The New American, July 20, 2026.
No comments:
Post a Comment